A dark day for the English game

The culture of racism endemic in english crickets infrastructure is blown open following Azeem Rafiq's emotional testimony

Whistleblower Azeem Rafiq testifies to a parliamentary panel

There is old idiom which plays to crickets history as a pastime of the quintessential English gentleman. It's anchored around the sports self proclaimed adherence to fairness and rectitude; a game which prides itself on maintaining the highest levels of sportsmanship, conduct, integrity and decency.

Whilst something of an old fashioned expression, it's not that uncommon in todays more modern lexicon, and it's use isn't restricted solely to sporting arenas. Anywhere an apparent injustice occurs or there are questionable actions by others we'll often here somebody comment "that's just not cricket".

However, what was heard yesterday in The Wilson Room at Portcullis House, calls into question any claim the game of cricket might have on being the bastion of what could reasonably be considered appropriate or gentlemanly behavior.

It's patently clear the game in England has an institutional problem with racism.

As much as the establishment would want to convince us all otherwise there is a very deeply seeded bigotry towards anything that doesn't look exactly like a younger versions of what stares back from a mirror of the old white men charged with running the game.

Listening to Azeem Rafiq's tearful and emotional testimony yesterdays before the DCMS (Digital, Culture Media and Sport) select committee hearing made for uncomfortable listening.

This was a man who has been dragged through the media ringer in the weeks and months following his initial public revelation to the racist treatment he received whilst a player with Yorkshire. With yesterdays hearing affording him the protection of parliamentary privilege, he took the opportunity to not only repeat previous allegations but go on to voice previously unheard charges.

Take for instance Alex Hales, who named his dog Kevin simply because it was black is an astonishing revelation. Whilst Hales has categorically denied there was anything maleficent about this; it's hard see how there wasn't at least some influence here from the names other use. "Kevin" had been used by white players at Yorkshire as a replacement for Asian players real names that had been deemed to hard to pronounce.

Given how Hales is already something of a pariah within the England set up, behavior like this makes it all the more obvious why Eion Morgan has continued to keep Alex at arms length from the England senior squad.

The initial defence from officials at Yorkshire CCC, was that his treatment was little more than harmless good-natured "banter" and as such was little more than a natural culture between players and something that Rafiq should just have accepted.

Working in the software product design space as I do, one of the key learnings I've made over the years is very few things in life are truly binary. There is nuance everywhere. But with all that said quite what planet somebody needs to be on to consider the slur P**i as acceptable "banter" remains to be seen. The use of such a term has always carried an intention to cause harm. There can be no question of this.

Anyone pretending differently is at best deeply ignorant too what todays society views acceptable; and - as is most likely - carrying deeply rooted bigotry which they have no problem expressing publically. They know full well the etymology of such language, and use it with the full intention of causing offence.

Yorkshires defence went further still. In addition to wanting to dilute the severity of such behavior, it deemed it appropriate to try and turn the tables on Azeem, and defame the reputation of their accuser by suggesting he himself had partaken in xenophobic "derogatory" abuse of an unnamed player of Zimbabwean origin.

What truths there are to this are hard to tell, and Rafiq would not be human if he wasn't to have some flaws in this history. I suspect should anything surface to cause question on his character then he would be the frist to stand up and own it, and where needed appologise accordingly.

But we digress. Here's the thing about banter. Nobody is saying that in it's self it's wrong. Far from it. Under the right circumstances the existence of should be seen as a signal to a strong culture and emotional bond amongst a team. But the relationships and intentions need to be sound; and all parties need to be very clear of the boundaries and rules of such interactions.

Paul Shina put this best in his response to YCCCs statment

Whilst much of reaction to Yorkshires statement across media outlets was largely one of astonishment; the most telling response came from the clubs commercial partners and sponsors. One by one over the following days millions of pounds in revenue the county would have been relying on was taken off the table as agreements and contracts with sponsors were torn up.

The financial impact of this loss - somewhat depressingly - seemed to be the focus of particular attention from one of the MPs in yesterdays committee hearing. Giles Watling Conservative party MP for Clacton used his opportunity to question Rafiq by focusing on his potential willingness to work with the club to "help them get their sponsorship back".

For Giles - an ageing white man - too centre his questioning around how the victim might partake in fixing the consequences of others actions, misses the point spectacularly. It's not the victims responsibility to do this in any circumstance.

Rafiq deflected this line of question graciously; but the mere fact that such a concept was even broached signals that there is much work to be done. It was a lazy line of questioning for which Watling should be challenged over. In the list of things that need fixing in this situation; the attractiveness of Yorkshire County Cricket club to potential commercial partners is bottom of a very long line.

What ever steps are taken by the games leadership to begin addressing these wider issues of racism, there is one thing that can be assured. In the fallout from these revelations the careers of some players - former and current - are toast. Whether you agree with the legitimacy of such consequences or want to argue it's another example of "the woke brigade getting more people cancelled" it's hard to denny there wont be some who have to pay a costly price

One of those named in the report - former England captain Michael Vaughn - has tried to get out ahead of the allegations and deemed it appropriate to use the privilege his platform as a Daily Telegraph columnist affords him to deny any wrong doing on his part. Not just once but twice once another player Adil Rashid had confirmed they'd heard Michael make derogatory remarks.

Michael Vaughn will likely find his bbc media career is now over
Image credit: New Zealand Herald

Vaughn's defence - for now at least - seems to be based around questioning how his accusers can be convinced of details in historical conversations; whilst he himself is exempt of such a fragile memory and is adamant no such words passed his lips.

Setting aside the hypocrisy of such a defence; it's very apparent that Michael is either getting very poor advice from a PR crisis management team or - more likely - he's is being advised wisely and choosing to ignore it.

Digging in like this, will likely not end well. The optics of his tactics here scream of arrogance and for many largely only serves to confirm the a personality type capable of the actions Azeem has alleged. I cant help but be reminded of similarly strong denials of wrong doing by a former US President. "I did not have sexual relation with that woman..." anyone?

No doubt in his own mind he is utterly convinced of his innocence; but is it really that much of a stretch for him to acknowledge theres a chance that perhaps - just perhaps - he might have used language that caused distress? Seems to me there's a distinct lack of self awareness towards the possibility that, however unintentionally, he could have acted in a way that his team mates from the Asian communities found deeply offensive.

This inability to look inward, admit that he might be flawed, and seek forgiveness is ultimately what is likely to cost Vaughn his job. At least with the BBC; who will not look kindly on this stance here. As great a player as he was it looks like we might have heard the last of his voice as a permanent fixture on the BBC's TMS commentary team.

As much as many will see this as just another instance of the "woke left" getting their way and "cancelling" individuals for relatively small transgressions, the fall out from this evidence and report is going to cost him and others where it hurts. As it should be. Simply because an event happened years ago, does not suggest actions and behavior should be entirely consequence free.

Apologies shouldn't need to be so hard. From observations it feels that much of Azeem's motivations to blow the whistle on his experience have been based not on seeking punishment or compensation; but merely to receive an apology from those who wronged him. For there to be demonstrable contrition. Not just from individuals but the wider establishment who had largely turned a blind eye. Only now being willing to open there ears when the effect surfaces as holes in their balance sheets.

Take for example Matthew Hoggard a former team mate of Rafiq's at Yorkshire. As part of his testimony Azeem revealed Matthew had reached out quietly and in private too acknowledged he'd played a part and wanted to apologise. Something Azeem was gracious enough to accept.

See Michael, it's really not that hard.

But it's not just Vaughn who need to be taking a long hard look at themselves in the fallout from this report. Mark Arthur, the now former Chief Executive of Yorkshire CCC - seemingly declined to appear before the DCMS committee. It's not clear exactly why this is the case, but perhaps the new club chairman Lord Patel decided that his attendance would simply be too divisive given the circumstances. His club had handled the issue spectacularly badly, and the hearing was not about Yorkshire CCC taking the chance to speak. That moment was passed. It was time to listen and understand the damage they'd created before any real change can happen at the club.

Others at the club have been named, and will I'm sure face some uncomfortable times in the months ahead. This is a necessary step, though; and small price to pay for the distress their actions have caused in others. It will be interesting to see how - as these names come out - each of the accused address the revelations. How many will burry their heads and hope the problem simply goes away (spoiler alert - it wont) and which will show some remorse and work to be part of the

Yorkshire CCC director of cricket Martyn Moxon.
Image credit: Yorkshire Post

Martyn Moxon and Andrew Gale, both of whom are part of the on-field set up at Yorkshire have clearly played a significant role in allowing this behavior amongst players to go unchecked. Both of these individuals are charged not only with developing players games, but also carry accountability for developing them as humans. The physical and mental wellbeing of players are entrusted into the hands of these coaches, and the casual way in which they've flexed their self-perceived superiority over players from an Asian background has to be challenged.

As it stands Gale has been suspended and Moxon is on medical leave due to stress. Expect to see Gales termination made permanent in the coming days, with a Moxon resignation to follow. As, for both of them surely their positions are now untenable.

Frankly, from what has been reported around the clubs Moxon's handling of Azeem and his wife suffering a miscarriage, this will not be a bad thing. The game will be better for both of their absence, and should not be shy of cutting out anything malignant if it is to emerge from the other side of these revelations and be more welcoming to anyone from any culture.

For the casual observer, who perhaps is largely only exposed to the game at an international level, it would not be unreasonable to argue that big strides have not already been made with the integration Asian cultures into the game.

Since the days when Alistair Cook captained the side, England have worked hard to ensure that cultural sensitivities around alcohol in particular are respected. There have been numerous situations where post victory celebrations have tempered any spraying of champagne until such a point that the likes Moheen Ali or Adil Rashid are well clear of any contamination.

Alastair Cook (left) and England team players did not spill the champagne for some time so that Moeen Ali could be a part of the winning team picture
Image credit: India Today

Such an adjustment in behavior is appreciated by affected players, but it should be the norm, and not something the ECB use as PR spin to pat it's self on the back. It's a positive move for sure, but on it's own it's really only a token gesture.

Given the lens of the last few weeks it's clear there is significant work for the ECB to do to encouraging such an approach; and for it to happen not where it's visible and overt - but needs to seep down to all levels.

Whilst we are on the subject of the ECB. This summer finally saw the launch - to much fanfare - of their new flagship format, The 100. So, given quite how much was on the line for it's success (reportedly an investment someway north of £40m) after a delay of 12 months; it does seem like they took their eye of the ball when it came to everything else.

Perhaps the launch was so much of a distraction that officials at the ECB simply didn't register the conversation that Azeem was trying to make public. Or perhaps they heard, and hoped that with everything else going on, it would be drowned out and go away. That through pure attrition Azeem would tire and the conversation organically die off.

Which ever is the truth matters little to be honest. The optics of either are not great, and whilst much of the attention right now is focused on Yorkshire CCC players and officials, the ECB should not feel like they will survive this without some damage.

Throughout his entire testimony yesterday Azeem came across as an incredibly gracious and dignified man. Persevering through everything takes extraordinary courage, and it's abundantly clear there has been an emotional cost to him to have raised his voice as he has.

Now finally the conversations he's been trying to start are taking place. For over a year barely anyone listened but he persisted, driven by desire to make the game he once loved so dearly, one which truly embraces all cultures. He wanted to give hope to other Asian cricketers, to allow them to feel like they can find the courage to speak to their own experiences too.

There will be more stories to come. More tales which will make for grim reading and expose uncomfortable truths which need to be heard to enable the game to move forward.

But these stories must be heard, and they must be allowed to be a catalyst for change. Not everyone in the game is racist - nobody is pretending this is the case.

What is clear though; enough people are. Enough people are behaving in a way that is spoiling it for others; and enough people have stood bye, watched this go on and said nothing. They've been silent on what they've seen.

They may has well have given it a standing ovation.

Azeem's legacy hopefully depicts a brighter future for the game. Change will come. Sure there will be a cost, and the historical sporting achievements of some players will be tarnished. But this feels like an acceptable cost to prevent future generations from being subjected to anything resembling racially charged abuse.

Simply having a bit more eumelanin in the basal layer of their epidermis is never a reason to be on the end of abuse anywhere. Whether on a cricket field or otherwise.

Back to Home